Showing posts with label Italy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Italy. Show all posts

Monday, February 24, 2014

A new euro zone crisis in the making? The Bank of Italy's omen on stress testing

Today, the Bank of Italy proposed a bad bank for non-performing loans for the banks it supervises. The government is denying that there is a need for such a bank, that would have to have state guarantees for the loans the bank holds.

On November 4th of this year, the ECB is supposed to take over supervision for the EU's 128 largest banks. Before that happens, the ECB will undertake stress tests and identify amongst other things, non-performing loans that need to be cleaned up.

If the Bank of Italy's proposals were taken on board by the government, it would be a sign of economic responsibility in Italy to cleaning up its banking sector, but the political mentality appears to be twofold in Italy--that the state couldn't pay if it wanted to, and therefore that what you don't know won't kill you. But it will, and that will unleash a new crisis in the euro zone as the markets guess the level of the damage.


Friday, November 11, 2011

Authority, the public and the euro

Within the last 24 hours, Italy and Greece have gotten new heads of government. One is a former central banker. The other a former European Commissioner. Both favour the TINA approach to dealing with the euro zone crisis, that there is no alternative to those countries accepting their obligations, repaying their debts and staying within the euro zone.

There is merit in that approach, but only if the Greeks and Italians are fully on board with the changes that would have to happen. Those who work for the state, receive a pension, or have a contract with the public sector would have to be willing and able to live with far less income, however that is required. Private sector wages would have to decline. All of this would be required to ratchet back the expenses of the state, and to ratchet back the cost of production for export products. These dual measures are required to start reducing borrowing, reducing payouts, and earning more money. 

This means that Greece, Italy and Portugal must accept, if they go down this path, that the next generation is a lost one. Most of them will become poorer. The achievements they have made will be diminished. The lie of their prosperity, built on a bubble paid for by bondholders, will be exposed for the sham it is.

These are harsh words, and there are equally harsh words that can be pointed at the bondholders who lent their money to these countries. They are equally at fault for being so reckless and delusional in investing in countries like these without the recipients using that money as an investment in future productive income. That is the only kind of investment that the private sector should be undertaking. The worst part of all this is that we not only need to ask the pointed question of what kind of crack that asset managers at hedge funds were smoking when they treated these countries as equals of more productive countries, but why the other investment managers we expect to be more prudent were doing precisely the same. Pension fund managers and insurance managers were part of this as well.

If Greece, Portugal and even other countries were required to default on part of their debt, it would finally force creditor countries to start doing more than treating Southern Europe as the evil shadow of irresponsibility, recklessness and demise. It would force them to face questions about why they were the first in line with the money to give these countries.

Those are answers that voters in creditor countries should be demanding. Why is economic decision-making in the financial centres of Europe so irresponsible? A departure of Greece from the euro zone, as painful as it may be to begin with, would ultimately benefit both it and the euro zone. An important impact would be making euro zone membership more compatible with economic objectives again, as would be aligning membership with democratice choice. But the pressure it puts on financial centres will force some hard questions about why Europe's rich countries thought that their own economic welfare depended on speculation in a bubble in financial instruments, even if they were in government debt. What all of this has in common is that a short, sharp downturn could force a return to realistic assessments--of political motivations and political choices, not just in Greece, but everywhere in the EU. 

The new leadership of Italy and Greece is based on the premise that political authority can force a country to embrace low inflation and public borrowing. Chile has done that fairly successfully, but only through a military dictatorship. This will be the first attempt at such authoritarianism inside democracies. I almost wrote functioning democracies, but that is giving the countries too much credit at the present time.

This is a social science experiment of great proportions, the likes of which have not been seen for a very long time. Can you use public power to change who a people are and what they want?

We shall see.



Tuesday, September 20, 2011

France, Italy and the war's fluid front

China has stopped doing business with a number of French banks, and Siemens, for one company, has stopped as well. There is concern that the banks will be hit by a possible Greek default on public debt next month. A good amount of Greek debt will have to be paid or rolled over, the Greeks and the troika of EU, IMF and ECB have been at an impasse, and Germany has just announced that it can't possibly vote on new support until 2012. A default is coming, and the Chinese, who have excellent business acumen in these things, are pulling out.

The silver lining in this cloud is that they will probably be back, purchasing assets and shares at a bargain at a later date, but not before France is significantly weakened, and before the Chinese have strategic positions in French investment banks. Note that will come with political as well as economic influence.

Italy has also been downgraded, and the country is unable to find a replacement for the outgoing Berlusconi.

The war has extended beyond Greece, Portugal and Spain and is now rampaging in France and Italy. The Dutch and the Germans are retrenching budgets all the more to compensate and ringfencing themselves from the carnage. Spain seems to be holding the fort well enough.

This isn't the end of it. Indeed, because the Europeans will not support the economic stimulus plans that the US is proposing, there will be a downward spiral for the next decade in which employment, wages and general economic welfare in Europe will decline. The only people to benefit will be the ones with enough cash to buy in at a discount.

All of this assumes that a default doesn't happen, and/or that Greece remains in the euro. But leaving the common currency may not affect the other countries that are now in the midst of the war.

Assuming Greece stays, invest in emerging markets. Growth will not be happening in Europe for a while.


Monday, May 23, 2011

Default, deception and European debt

Europe has economic and political problems that just won't quit. There is a stench of desperation in the air that has gotten so strong that the President of the EU Council, Herman van Rompuy, has effectively told heads of government to STFU, lest they freak out the markets and send investors fleeing unnecessarily. On the contrary, Europe is suffering from a deep psychosis.

It's unlikely to make much difference unless there are real reasons for investors to think that Europe has its act together. And Europe doesn't. Standard and Poors has already downgraded bonds from Greece and Portugal to within a breath of junk bond status earlier this year. Those bonds, as well as those of Spain and Italy, are under renewed pressure as S&P considers a further downgrade of Italy.

The only question that anyone cares about, but that the politicians haven't accepted yet, is which of these countries will default on their debt this year, and by how much. If no default were likely, the problem would take care of itself. Imagine raking in the high interest payments on debt that you just bought for a big discount. The markets aren't buying it. Literally and figuratively.

Europe, with the exception of the ECB, (For its part, the ECB is demanding that the Greeks and everyone else pay in full, and that Europe reject any talk  of default, under whatever deceptive label it might come .) sent a strong message last week that it wants to let Greece default without actually calling it a default. A partial default is called a restructuring and is pretty common. But no one wants to say that. Talk started to circulate of 'soft restructuring', as if this would make an difference to anyone. When it was clear that it wouldn't, European finance ministers started talk of 're-profiling' the debt, which did nothing but slap a new label on an old plan. Last week, realising that someone would have to do something, the EU Council asked banks holding bonds from these countries not to ask for the money back.

Why does Europe think that banks and other institutional financial investors would hold on to such a crappy investment? It's the state equivalent of a sub-prime mortgage. Sooner or later, you want to get rid of it. The less confidence you have in the ability of the borrower, the sooner you want to sell. And if it isn't clear by now, holding on to that debt in the hope that it will be repaid, or at least that markets will re-invest in it at some point out of speculation, is hoping that a new economic bubble will wash the problems away. Or at least onto someone else's balance sheet.

That is a really bad idea. It's like a serious alcoholic who's trying to hide the booze bottles rather than admit having a problem and taking on the pain and responsibility of rehab. But lies and delusion don't make a problem go away. They prolong the disease and the agony. And everyone turns their backs on you.

Under these conditions, when Europe is deliberately trying to mislead the world about the depth of its problems, there are serious reasons to object to Europe insisting on its right to head the IMF. It wants to hold on to its prestige and power by birthright rather than merit, a point that is both legitimate and gaining steam internationally. It's like the town drunk, insisting on running the liquor store. Unless Europe shows a change of heart, that is another really bad idea. Europe hasn't hit bottom yet, and still thinks its in control.

It's time to take away the keys.